Last night over 30 residents, many Town Meeting members, rose to speak on the issue of the zoning overlay for the Temple Shalom property bringing the number of people heard close to 45; with slightly more speaking in favor than against. But it is not over yet.

Moderator Brian Walsh took the names of those waiting to speak at the end of last night’s session. He will call them tonight and when they have finished a vote will be taken.

The speakers in favor advocated for preserving the diversity, the added tax income and the amenities a tastefully executed commercial development could provide. The opponents argued the development is not of a scope and scale that fits the space, would adversely impact the quality of life (e.g. traffic congestion, noise, etc.) and would set a dangerous precedent for similar development in other parts of town.

It was a vigorous discussion and at one point required Mr. Walsh to gently admonish the audience stating that respect needed to be shown to all speakers. He also said speakers should not make comments that would incite a negative response. “This is a small town. It is a good town,” said Walsh.

But before all of this there was a small but very important tribute. Richard Wells, Chief of the Milton Police Department, was given the floor. Chief Wells then acknowledged Russell Withrow, an officer on the Milton Police Department, who is being activated in support of the military effort, “Iraqi Freedom.” Mr. Withrow received a standing ovation of appreciation . . . twice. Once when he rose to thank the Chief and the department for their support of his deployment and once when he quietly excused himself. May Godspeed Mr. Withrow.

The audience also heard from Pete Jackson, Chairman of the Planning Board who introduced Jeff Dirk of Vanasse Associates. Mr Dirk gave a presentation of the traffic assessment study his firm had done.

It was a long night, but before a vote can be taken, the people’s voices are heard. Following are some of the statements that have been made at this Special Town Meeting regarding Article 2. This is the zoning article that will enable Temple Shalom and their partner Coffman Realty to move forward with plans to put a CVS, Harvest Coop, and rebuilt temple on their land. It does not approve construction of this development but will allow the developer to apply for a special permit. This special permit requires a vote of 4 of the 5 Planning Board Members for approval. If the article does not pass, then the Temple will put the property on the market and they along with their tenant, The Campbell School, will need to find a new home.

In the spirit of the debate and in an attempt to capture the tenor of feelings expressed, here is some of what was said:

“Religious communities are precious and fragile . . . [it is] a huge mistake to put the Temple at risk.” — Dr. Jeffrey Johnson, Minister, First Congregational Church

“A smaller ship will suit us fine . . . where will we dock?” — Rabbi Benjamin, Temple Shalom

“A ‘no’ vote kills it – the Temple can’t survive. A ‘yes’ vote gives the Temple hope.” — Tom Smigliani

“I had an expectation of compromise.” — Tammy Murphy

“Not being heard and being disagreed with are two very different things.” — Keith Wicke

“I am against anything that will destroy the residential character of our neighborhood.” — Cheryl Fleitman

“No matter how I vote, I will make many people unhappy.” — Frank Giuliano

“There’s more than one way to do this. This has gone on long enough and I have gone on long enough too.” — Sophie Govatsos

“Starting over is not an option.” — Lynda Packer, President of Temple Shalom

“[the neighbors believed] the town and boards would protect them against people who would destroy it for profit.” — Lisa Murphy

“Change is the third certainty.” — Betsy Buchbinder

“No matter how thin you slice it . . .if you pass article 2 you are establishing spot zoning.” — Joseph Manning

“Allow history to repeat itself and erect another vibrant shopping area.” — Nancy Kearns

“Today’s buyer is looking for amenities.” — Caroline Cahill, Realtor

“If you vote to recommend something you are not sure of, because you fear the alternative will cause you to lose control, then haven’t we already lost control of the process.” — Catherine King

“Thank you for letting me speak though I know you want to go to sleep.” — Ms. Ali

(Note: You can watch a replay of the meeting on MATV. Check their programming guide for air times.)

The last to speak at Town Meeting is the Town Moderator and this is what he said:

“My intent is to vote this tomorrow.” — Brian Walsh