Opinion / Commentary

About those street lights

The street light outside our house has been turned back on. It shines through my son’s bedroom window functioning as a poor man’s night light.

Personally, we liked having it off. There was a quietude about the street with the darkness. However, we live on a very short street with very little traffic.

Clearly issues of safety and security exist in other areas of town. The Selectmen’s decision to turn them back on is understandable. The cost savings weren’t being realized to the extent they had hoped, certain roadways were more hazardous as a result of the lack of light, and a sizable number of residents protested.

But it was worth a try. We hope this experience does not make the Selectmen gun shy of attempting cost-saving measures going forward that could be potentially unpopular. (Note – this was a decision made by town meeting but the selectmen tend to bear the brunt of, well, everything.) The Selectmen did the right thing.

A story ran in today’s Globe regarding the street light decision(s). You can find it here.

In AP effort, students soar – and teachers unions flunk

The Boston Globe ran an editorial this past week taking the Massachusetts Teachers Association to task over their opposition to an Exxon funded program to “train, recruit, and reward” teachers of AP classes. Milton is mentioned in the editorial as dropping out of the program.

from The Boston Globe

TEACHERS UNIONS see red on the subject of merit pay. But the results released yesterday on a bold education experiment suggest that paying teachers for performance helps in preparing students for college-level work. (You can read the full editorial here.)

This Override Matters! Vote YES on Monday, 6/8

MyTownMatters Commentary

by Frank Schroth

It is difficult to imagine what life will be like in this town if we fail to pass the contingent override budget that is on the ballot in Milton’s special election this coming Monday, June 8th.

An entity remains financially viable by controlling costs and maintaining revenue. Milton has three significant costs: salaries, pensions, and insurance. It has two key revenue streams: property taxes and state aid. State aid has been cut so now we have a significant shortage of revenue.

The loss of revenue requires cuts in services. These cuts have been identified by the respective department heads at town meeting and numerous public forums. (Please see the links at the end of this post).

So this override matters. It matters because the outcome will directly affect our lives and the lives of our children.

If it fails to pass the town’s bond rating may be at risk. Kevin Sorgi, town treasurer for the pasat 28 years, has said that one reason Milton had the solid bond rating it did was due to the willingness to pass overrides to ensure the town services did not deteriorate.

Without the override the cuts to the school system will be so substantial that the schools may be at risk of being put on probation. Thirty-two teachers will be let go and classroom sizes may balloon to ~30.

We will not be as safe and secure in our homes. A fire station will close and 5 police officers will be relieved of duty. It is reasonable to expect response times to slow.

Maybe Milton property values, which to date have been fairly resilient given the recession, will continue to hold their value despite these risks or maybe not.

These are risks that some voters might be willing to take.

But when it comes to the town’s students it is not about risk, it is about loss. The cuts to the schools are a reduction in opportunities for the students. In the words of one school committee person, the schools would be “seriously diminished.” As adults we would not feel any of this; but the students will. Their opportunities will be diminished; their life experiences diminished; their chances for success, diminished. And following from that it is not too much of a stretch to say that all of our futures will be diminished.

We cannot let that happen. Vote YES on Monday, June 8th to ensure the town’s safety and security, it’s sound bond rating, it’s accredited schools, and the quality educational experience the town’s children should have.

Related links

> Invest in Milton: Web SiteBlog
> Phil Matthews / Milton View: “What’s at Stake
> MHS senior Siobahn O’Grady’s speech to Town Meeting
> Property Tax Impact Table

> Videos
– Chief Wells: Cops Count
– Warrant Chairman Tom Hurley’s TM presentation
– Superintendent Mary Gormley’s TM presentation
– Selectmen Chairman John Shields speech to Town Meeting

FrankTalk: Brian Kelly tells it like it is

MyTownMatters Commentary

by Frank Schroth

Finally someone tells it like it is.

Last Thursday we attended the open forum hosted by the Milton School Administration and School Committee.

The forum was held to provide parents and concerned citizens an opportunity to speak and ask questions regarding the steps the school will take if an override fails and they are forced to meet a non-contingent budget.

In short, the school will cut 45 head count system wide, class sizes will on average swell to 30 or more, the high school’s accreditation could be at risk, and logistical challenges will arise in attempts to manage French Immersion across the 4 elementary schools that have to stay open.

Not surprisingly, parents who attended the forum were upset at the implications. A range of concerns were voiced: parents questioned if learning can possibly take place in a class that has more than thirty students; some questioned the value of the French Immersion, some expressed dismay that they had recently moved to town because of the school system program and now look what happened. One parent moved his family to Milton for French Immersion program.

And then Brian Kelly spoke.

A frank talk with Charlie McCarthy, candidate for Town Treasurer

There may be someone in Milton who speaks with more confidence and authority about this town and its government than Charlie McCarthy, but it is hard to think of who that might be.

McCarthy is largely a self made man. And like most entrepreneurs, he will tell you, “I always see a glass that’s half full.

We met at McCarthy’s house. Looking out his kitchen window, McCarthy pointed to a series of raised beds where he plants stuff every spring. A lot of people know McCarthy, but who knew he was a farmer?

But this spring he may not have time to get down on his knees. This year the campaign season is interfering with the sowing season.

Who is Charlie McCarthy?

Charlie McCarthy

Charlie McCarthy

Charlie McCarthy is a product of the Milton Public Schools who has served the town in ways both appointed (Warrant Committee) and elected (Board of Selectmen).

McCarthy has managed his own businesses for 20+ years. Initially, he was a contractor and managed a team that installed equipment at factories and manufacturing firms.  As a small businessmen, he has had to deal with budgets, audits, payroll and taxes. After a while, the travel and the requirements of the job came up against family life and the fact that he wasn’t getting any younger. Installing conveyor belts and the like 20 feet above a factory floor somewhere hundreds of miles from home and family got tiring. So he recast his business.

Now he is a manufacturer’s representative. As a result, his life is saner and travel less frequent. He likes his lot in life, saying that in considering whether to run for treasurer, “I had to think long and hard about [possibly] leaving this business.”

Why Charlie McCarthy for Treasurer?

Not surprisingly, McCarthy believes his extensive experience in service to the town provides him with a unique knowledge and understanding of the office of  Treasurer that the other candidates cannot match.

As chairman of the Warrant committee, he relied heavily on the financial projections given him by the Town Treasurer Kevin Sorgi. And he appreciates that those projections “are as much art as science.” As an example ,he cited estimating revenue from excise taxes. The amount of revenue driven by excise taxes is a function of the age of the cars owned by residents, the number of new cars to be bought, and the relative price points. That is not an easy number to pin down.

He also interacted with the Treasurer as a Selectman, but McCarthy does not rely solely on his experience with the position and insights it has given him. “I have done my homework.” Keeping him company on his dining room table are the last two Town of Milton Annual Reports along with a hefty copy of the Treasurers Manual. “I’ve read it cover to cover.” He then commences on a discussion of town funds– those the Treasurer is responsible for administering versus those for which he is simply the custodian. He speaks about the responsibilities and what he views as the priorities of the office. He is clear on that: managing cash flow.

What comes through as McCarthy speaks is not just confidence but a certain enthusiasm. As he will plainly tell you, “Every minute of every day, I am trying to learn.

A frank talk with Janet Lorden, candidate for Town Treasurer

When it came time for us to meet, Janet Lorden could not get out of her garage.

The power had gone out on her street and the garage door opener wasn’t working. But Nstar sprung her free, and we eventually sat down at the new library to discuss her run for Town Treasurer.

Of the three candidates for Town Treasurer, Ms. Lorden is the one complete political neophyte. And she knows that, explaining “It will be an uphill battle and that’s fine. I’m knocking on doors and the reactions of people keeps me going.”

Who is Janet Lorden?

She moved to Milton in 1993 and lives with her husband and two children (twins!) on Brush Hill Road. Their children attend the Tucker School, which they love.

Janet Lorder

Janet Lorden

Raised with a strong sense of civic engagement, Lorden has a history of community service. She has volunteered with Training, Inc., a national network of local job training organizations that assist low income individuals to learn skills to achieve gainful employment. Here in Boston, Training, Inc. is sponsored by the Boston YMCA. Most recently, Lorden assisted a community effort in setting up a trust fund for the Revelus family: “Milton Cares: A Fund for the Revelus Family”.

She has worked in financial services for 20+ years; first with The Boston Company, followed by Eaton Vance, and then Fidelity Investments. And why financial services? Lorden says, “I love math. I love the logic of it, and I love the creativity of it.”

Why Janet Lorden for Treasurer?

When asked why she is the candidate of choice, Lorden is clear. “The treasurer role is a role I know.” She believes that she is the only candidate who possesses a thorough knowledge of: tax reporting not only to the IRS, but to states and at times down to the municipal level;  buying and selling investment vehicles as a licensed professional; and mangement of retirement products. And she believes this skill set is a requirement for performing the job well. This is an opinion she reiterated when we discussed whether the Town Treasurer should be an elected or appointed position.

All the candidates are on the record and in agreement that the office of Town Treasurer should be an elected one. However, Lorden thinks a better approach that would get a better result is one in which the candidates are recommended by a committee that puts forward candidates that are the best qualified. She questions whether the other candidates running for Treasurer have the necessary financial knowledge and experience. She suspects “they don’t understand the nuances and intricacies of investing. They don’t know the questions to ask.”

In addition, according to Lorden, “I know how to reduce costs and make things as efficient as possible.

03.22.09 – The Week That Was: sorrow, tragedy, and loss

At this time last week we were attending the wake for Nicholas Burdett, son Dr. Noreen Diamond Burdett, Director of the Music Programs in the Milton Public Schools. Nicholas Burdett was 25 years old and had gone to Miami with his girlfriend to celebrate his birthday. He was shot and killed by an off duty police officer. The officer alleges that Mr. Burdett was attempting to rob him at knife point. It is very hard to understand.

Several hundred people attended the wake to demonstrate their love and support for the family. We are very sorry for Dr. Burdett, a woman who has given so much to so many, and her family.

The Planning Board held a meeting in which they heard Temple Shalom and Coffman Realty respond to the concerns voiced by citizens regarding the redevelopment of the Temple’s property. You can read the orginal post here. The Planning Board will be meeting this Tuesday to pick up the discussion of the issue. Regardless of how this ends, there will be a loss. In the minds of the neighbors they worry the character of their neighborhood will be lost if the proposal passes. If it fails to pass, the town will lose its only synagogue and a well regarded pre-school. As Mr. Mays, who spoke at an early “Citizens Speak” said, there will be change, “and no one is going to be happy.”

And then there was the tragic event that unfolded on Bevoir Street on Saturday. Kerby Revelus killed two of his sisters, Bianca, aged 5, and Samantha, aged 17.  He was attacking his third sister, Saraphina, when the police broke into the apartment and shot him. They saved Saraphina’s life.

Frankly, there are no words to capture the pain, the heartbreak, and the loss experienced by the family, their friends, and the town.

But Milton is a strong community. Tomorrow the Milton School Administration is hosting a forum to discuss the loss and how to cope with it. The discussion will be at Milton High School, tomorrow night (3/30) @ 7:00pm.

Milton High Musicians receive acclaim at state level

Three Milton High School musicians will be performing in the All-State concerts to be held at the Seaport Hotel and Boston’s Symphony Hall. They are Marline Alexis, Elain Daiber, and Charlie Rosmarin.

This is an extraordinary achievement. Thousands of students compete for these opportunities. For a system of Milton’s size to have one would be amazing but to have three is outstanding.

Congratulations to Marline, Elaine, and Charlie!

But it does not end there. Dr. Noreen Diamond Burdett will be receiving the Visionary Lesdership Award given by the state organization, Adminstrators in Music Education.

Please give it up for Dr. Burdett!

GO WILDCATS!!

Who’s Hoosac?

Their full name is the Hoosac Valley Hurricanes and they will play the Milton Wildcats in the MIAA division 2 final in Worcester on Saturday at 4:00 PM. And to read about them, they sound a lot like, well, the Wildcats: gritty, disciplined, defensive minded, have a good bench and have a lot of heart. Their firecracker is forward Robbie Burke; but it does not begin or end with him. They are a complete team. It will be a great match up.

You can read about Hoosac’s semifinal playoff game against St Bernard’s of Fitchburg here.

GO WILDCATS!!

School Choral Groups Perform to packed house

The Milton School Choral groups gave rousing performances last night in one of three concerts to be held this month as part of the “Music in Our Schools Month” celebration.

The Pierce Middle School 6th Grade Chorus kicked things off, appropriately enough, with “Let There Be Song”. And was there ever. The singing barely stopped for the next hour and a half. The singing continued even in between choral acts. In an innovative bit of programming, members of the ensembles, sprinkled about the audience, sang Disney songs during the transition from one group to the next. The audience was encouraged to sing along with the lyrics to such favorites as “Whistle While You Work”(Snow White), “Under the Sea” (The Little Mermaid),Bibbidi-Bobbidi-Bo” ( Cinderella), included in the program.

Pierce Middle School Honors Chorus

Ms Sykes and the Pierce Middle School Honors Chorus